Your browser version is outdated. We recommend that you update your browser to the latest version.

Dead woman's eye-loss case cannot go ahead

Posted 17/11/2016

A legal action for damages by an elderly woman who died before her appeal against the dismissal of her case was decided cannot be continued for the benefit of her estate, the Supreme Court has ruled.

Bridget Doyle was aged 79 when she underwent surgery at the Royal Victoria Eye and Ear Hospital in January 2010 to remove a cataract from her left eye.

The surgery was unsuccessful, and post-operative complications required removal of that eye in February 2010 to prevent damage to her right eye.

Further complications arose, requiring further interventions in 2010 and 2012, and this left her often depressed and reliant on family members for care.

In June 2011, she initiated proceedings alleging she had not given informed consent to the surgery and administration of a general anaesthetic. The claims were denied.

In December 2013, Mr Justice Eamon De Valera gave judgment dismissing her claim. An appeal was lodged in January 2014, but Mrs Doyle passed away on July 11 of that year.

The proceedings were reconstituted and the Supreme Court directed a hearing on whether the cause of action survived her death.

Her side said the claim for general damages survived, plus a claim for €90,000 for care services provided by Edward Doyle to his mother between 2010 and 2012

About us    

We have been providing legal services for over 50 years to expansive range of clients.

We provide a personal service in a convenient location.  Solving problems is not always easy as people and institutions are not always rational.  Therefore, we often have to fight our client's causes when compromise cannot be reached.   We act in cases in the District Court up to the Supreme Court and we have successfully secured millions of euros for our clients. 

Our firm also has vast experience in residential and commercial property law.  We have acted for developers, banks and other institutions in that sale and purchase of thousands of units worth in excess of €1 billion. 


 Dublin Solicitors and Notary Public

Why use a solicitor? 

Solicitors are educated and trained to the highest standards through the Law Society’s Professional Practice Course, a blend of practice-oriented taught modules and in-office training with law firms.

Life-long professional development and training

Qualified solicitors are required to further their expertise on an annual basis by attending courses to attain a minimum number of continuing professional development points.

The Society’s committees develop and publish a continuous stream of practice notes on new developments in the various fields of law and aspects of legal practice.

High professional and ethical standards

Solicitors are held to high professional and ethical standards and are regulated by the Law Society of Ireland’s Regulation Department.



National Solicitors Alliance Solicitors Alliance